posted on: Tuesday, April 15, 2008

A Compromised Charitable Sector
By Gary R. Snyder

If anyone thought that the bright light on nonprofit misdeeds was going to fade with the change in Senate Finance Committee leadership they are grossly underestimating the festering problem. Granted the loss of Dean A. Zerbe as a principal staff point person on this matter to Ranking Member Senator Charles Grassley is a significant blow. The direction may have changed but the intense interest in setting the nonprofit sector straight has not subsided.

The Senate Finance Committee’s ongoing concern in nonprofit ineptitude was joined by the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee, which held hearings. Among the embarrassing issues was how veterans’ charities gave small proportions of revenue to veterans and their families. An article in the Chronicle of Philanthropy stated that committee members used terms such as “immoral”, “fraud” and “sickening betrayal” with a promise to have additional hearings as the issues unfold.

These terms of endearment are consistent with the donor’s diminishing confidence in the charitable sector. Heightened scrutiny has resulted in increased stories in the media with the recent study on $30-40 billion annual nonprofit fraud (Greenlee, Gordon) being unveiled in an arresting New York Times (March 29, 2008, Report Sketches Crime Costing Billions: Theft From Charities) article. The cumulative effect of the focus of the public attention on charity malfeasance is still unknown, but certainly isn’t going to play well in Congress or at the local nonprofit agency.

The problems continue to center on the abuses by the board, executive and volunteers. All have failed to be diligent in exercising their fiduciary duties. As the Independent Sector notes, few know what their responsibilities are. Even if they did understand what their role is supposed to be, few have the skills to adequacy address the misdeeds.

This is underscored by the Independent Sector’s Panel on the Nonprofit Sector request for government assistance in educating board and professional leaders because both are not aware of the expectations and requirements imposed upon them.

While tens of billions of dollars are taken from those to which it is intended, sector leaders continue to say that it is a “few bad apples”. Last year, the General Accounting Office noted that nearly 55,000 tax-exempt organizations had almost $1 billion in unpaid taxes with some owing tens of millions of dollars.

The fallout in loss in the nation’s misdeeds from charities is profound. According to the National Priorities Project----a $20 billion loss is equivalent to any of the following:

• healthcare to 7.721 million people, or
• 438,768 public safety officials, or
• 1861 new elementary school, or
• 3.1 million Head Start places for children, or
• 290,081 elementary school teachers, or
• 299,496 port container inspectors
or, $54,794,520 per day

Leadership at the local, state, and national levels is virtually nonexistent. The use of words such as transparency and accountability have become jargon—buzzwords---that fail to be meaningful without substance behind them.

The sole of the charitable world is under scrutiny. Integrity, credibility and effectiveness are proxy measures of the soundness of any organization. Without those, the sector is severely compromised


Gary R. Snyder is the author of Nonprofits: On the Brink. He is a frequent lecturer and author of articles in numerous publications and blogs. His email is gary.r.snyder@gmail.com; website: http://garyrsnyder.com, phone: 248.324.3700.